A. The
Incident
At about 1230 hours on 21 July 2002, in good visibility and weather,
a mainland sand barge "番運機169" collided
with the bow of a mainland cargo vessel "787" anchored at approximately
0.40 nautical miles (nm) north west of "Pun Shan Shek Light" in
the Pun Shan Shek anchorage. "興海787" had
no apparent damage after the collision while "番運機169" sustained hull damage at the
starboard quarter in way of the engine room. Water entered
the engine room shortly after the collision. As the situation
deteriorated "169" went adrift and sank in position 22 16.68'N 114 05.57'E,
about 0.7 nm east of Kau Yi Chau. All crew
members of "番運機169" jumped
overboard and were rescued by a passing vessel. There was
no injury to the crew in this incident.
B. Findings
The Master of "番運機169" had
failed to keep clear of the anchored vessel "興海787" when he knew that the starboard
engine of his vessel was not working properly. Despite difficulties
in controlling his vessel, he however attempted to continue to
proceed and pass close to the vessels at anchor.
C. The Lessons
Knowing the difficulties in controlling the vessel with only
one single engine of a twin screw ship, the master should navigate
his vessel away from the anchored ships to allow more sea room
and proceed with extreme caution. To allow the vessel to proceed
to its destination whilst passing close to other anchored vessels
would create danger not only to own ship but also to other vessels
in the vicinity. Besides the ships anchored in the area, the master
should also consider the safety of navigation throughout the passage
taking into account the state of maneuverability of his vessel.
Position of Collision
Photograph of a sand carrier similar to "番運機169"
Photograph of "興海787"
Back
|